A Critique and Evaluation of Gadamer's Philosophical Hermeneutics Based on the Criteria of the Interpreter with Emphasis on the Interpretive Views of Allameh Tabatabaei

Document Type : Original Article

Author

PhD in Comparative Interpretation of the Qur'an and lecturer in Islamic seminary and the university. Kowsar Higher Islamic Sciences Education Complex. Tehran Iran.

Abstract

The purpose of the present study is to answer the question of how Gadamer's philosophical hermeneutics can be criticized and evaluated according to the criteria of the interpreter of the Qur'an. This critique and evaluation is carried out via a descriptive-analytical method and with emphasis on the interpretive views of Allameh Tabatabaei. The study of this issue indicates that Gadamer's philosophical hermeneutics is one of the different styles of knowledge of the text comprehension process, which by focusing on the nature of text comprehension (for example, sacred texts) and considering the author and interpreter's criteria such as prejudice and historicity in comprehension as the same items, has created an endless period of text comprehension process and by giving full authority to the interpreter, has led to pluralism in understanding the text and, in fact, interpreting the based on their own ideas. This view can be criticized according to the interpretive views of Allameh Tabatabaei. By presenting criteria such as fair judgment and inference, avoiding the interests and preconceptions of the interpreter in understanding the text, he has not ignored the role and purpose of the author. Therefore, it has caused a quantitative and qualitative expansion of understanding of the text (sacred texts) and efficiency and lack of interpretation based on their own ideas and imposing the tastes and theories of the interpreter on the text.

Keywords

References

  1. * The Holy Qur'an

    * Nahj al-Balaghah

    1. Al-Awsi, A. (1405 AH). Al-Tabatabaei va Manhajoho fi Tafsir al-Mizan. Tehran: Islamic Propaganda Organization Publications. [In Arabic]
    2. Behjatpour, A. (1391 AP). Tafsir Fariqain. (history, Fundamentals, principles, sources). Qom: Exquisite works. [In Persian]
    3. Gadamer, H. G. (2006). Philosophy of Interpretation. (Principles, Fundamentals, Objectives) (Shoghi Al-Zain, M. Trans.). Algeria: Al-Dar al-Arabiyah le al-
    4. Grunden, J. (1393 AP). Hermeneutics. (Abolghasemi, M. R. Trans.) Tehran: Mahi. [In Persian]
    5. Heidegger, M. et al. (1377 AP). Modern Hermeneutics (A collection of papers). (Ahmadi, B., & Mohajer, M., & Nabavi, M. Trans.). Tehran: Markaz Publications. [In Persian]
    6. Hirsch, E. D. (1967). Validity in Interpretation, New Haven and London, Yale University.
    7. Javadi Amoli, A. (1390 AP). Interpretation of Tasnim. Qom: Isra'. [In Persian]
    8. Javadi Amoli, A. (n.d.). Interpretive style of Allameh Tabatabaei; Biography of Allameh Tabatabaei, Qom.
    9. Kalle, P. (2009). Reconsidering Relativism and Intentionalism in Interpretation, University of Helsinki.
    10. Khomeini, R. (1372 AP). Interpretation of Surah Hamd. Qom: Institute for Organizing and Publishing the Works of Imam Khomeini. [In Persian]
    11. Lesani Fesharaki, M. A. (1360 AP). A concise description of al-Mizan. Tehran: Muslim Women Movement. [In Persian]
    12. Mueller Vollmer, K., & Basil Blackwell. (1986). The Hermeneutics Reader.
    13. Ostadi, R. (1383 AP). Familiarity with interpretations of the Qur'an. Tehran: Quds Publications. [In Persian]
    14. Qudsi, A. (1372 AP). Principles and rules of inference from the Qur'an and Hadith. Qom: Imam Khomeini Institute. [In Persian]
    15. Saeedi Roshan, M. B. (1376 AP). Reasons or grounds for the revelation of Quranic verses. Qom: Zamzam Hedayat. [In Persian]
    16. Schmidt, L. K. (1395 AP). An Introduction to Hermeneutic Understanding. Tehran: Qoqnous. [In Persian]
    17. Tabatabaei, S. M. H. (1386 AP). Quran in Islam. Qom: Bustan Kitab. [In Persian]
    18. Tabatabaei, S. M. H. (1393 AH). Al-Mizan fi Tafsir al-Qur'an. Beirut: Al-A'alami. [In Arabic]
    19. Wachterhauser, B. (2002). Getting it Right: Relativism, Realism, and Truth, in The Cambridge Companion to Gadamer, (Robert J. Ed.). Dostal, New York, Cambridge University press.
    20. Warnke, G., & Gadamer, Hermeneutic. (1987). Tradition and Reason, Polity Press.
    21. Weberman, D. (2000). A New Defense of Gadamer's Hermeneutics. Philosophy and Phenomenological Review 60, no.1 (January), pp. 45-

     

     

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics